SEASON OF GIVING: DONATE TO THE LES SCHWAB TOY DRIVE AND THE Q13 FOX SOCK DRIVE

Victims in rural Tennessee slayings include suspect’s mom, dad and a 12-year-old girl

Michael Cummins is in custody in connection to five slayings in northern Tennessee. Full Credit: Tennessee Bureau of Investigations

At least three of the seven people killed in Sumner County, Tennessee, were related to the suspect in the slayings, including his mother, father and uncle, Tennessee Bureau of Investigation Director David Rausch said Monday.

The victims also included three generations of another family, a 12-year-old girl among them, and a woman who is not related to Cummins, Rausch told reporters. The victims were likely dead for more than a day upon being discovered, he said.

Michael Cummins, the 25-year-old suspect in the case, is hospitalized after being shot by a sheriff’s deputy. His injuries are not life-threatening. He has not been formally charged.

An eighth victim, also Cummins’ relative, is in the hospital in critical condition, Rausch said.

Authorities discovered six of the bodies and the injured victim off a rural road between Westmoreland and Fairfield, small towns located about 50 miles northeast of Nashville. A seventh body was found at a home less than a mile from the primary crime scene, police said.

The victims were identified as follows:

  • Cummins’ dad, David Carl Cummins, 51,
  • the suspect’s mom, Clara Jane Cummins, 44,
  • his uncle, Charles Edward Hosale, 45,
  • Rachel Dawn McGlothlin-Pee, 43, whose relationship to Cummins is unknown,
  • McGlothlin-Pee’s daughter, Sapphire, 12,
  • McGlothlin-Pee’s mother, Marsha Elizabeth Nuckols, 64,
  • and Shirley Fehrle, 69, who is not related to Cummins.

Tennessee investigators said the home where six of the victims were found dead over the weekend was one of the most complex and gruesome crime scenes they’d ever encountered.

“This is one of the most horrific cases that I’ve ever had to encounter and deal with,” said District Attorney Ray Whitley, who has been in his position since 1980.

Added Sheriff Sonny Weatherford, who has been in law enforcement since 1983, “I’ve never seen anything that would even come close to this.”

A family member called police Saturday after finding four of the bodies, and the TBI quickly announced investigators had found a fifth body at a nearby home.

The next day, the bureau said it had found two more bodies at the first house. Investigators declined to say how the victims were killed, citing the ongoing investigation.

After Cummins was identified as the suspect, police said, a search plane located him in a creek bed about a mile from the first home. More than a dozen SWAT team officers converged on the creek, the TBI said.

“The situation escalated, for reasons under investigation, and resulted in at least one officer firing his service weapon, striking Cummins,” the TBI said, adding that no officers were hurt.

Cummins has a criminal history and was most recently released from prison in January, officials said, declining to elaborate.

Notice: you are using an outdated browser. Microsoft does not recommend using IE as your default browser. Some features on this website, like video and images, might not work properly. For the best experience, please upgrade your browser.