Q13 FOX Season of Giving

Mixed-up morgue mistakenly tells family that dead woman ‘not your daughter’

This is an archived article and the information in the article may be outdated. Please look at the time stamp on the story to see when it was last updated.

Jade Aubrey Peterson, 25, (pictured) was hit by a pickup truck and killed in Spanaway last Friday night. But her body was misidentified by the Pierce County Medical Examiner’s Office as Samantha Kennedy, 24, because of confusion over a tattoo. Samantha is alive.  The mistake has angered the families of both women.  (Photo: Facebook page, courtesy of family)

SPANAWAY, Wash. — Two families have been devastated by a mix-up by the Pierce County Medical Examiner’s Office, where staff misidentified the body of a woman killed in a traffic accident last week.

Kathleen Aubrey spends her days looking at pictures of her late 25 year-old daughter, Jade.

“She was a beautiful person, she loved animals. She loved helping people,” Aubrey said Thursday.

Jade was killed last Friday night, when she was hit by a pickup truck while crossing a street in Spanaway.  Her family was worried when they heard about the accident a few days later, because they knew Jade had been staying in the area.

“I called around to the police station, sheriff’s office, and nobody could give me any information,” Aubrey said. “So I called the coroner’s office. They said the body’s already been claimed, don’t worry about it, it’s not your daughter.”

The Pierce County Medical Examiner’s Office had mixed up some information about a tattoo on the victim, and incorrectly identified her as 24-year-old Samantha Kennedy, who had been reported missing by a friend.

Samantha’s mother, Lori Baker, was notified her daughter had been killed. Baker said that when she asked to view the body, she was told she would have to wait until it was taken to a funeral home. She didn’t find out her daughter was still alive until Wednesday.

“Three days,” said Baker. “Three days thinking my kid was dead, because the police come and told me.”

She doesn’t think this terrible mix-up would have happened if the medical examiner had allowed her to see the body right away.

“There would have been that hour of shock and disbelief, and that would have been it,” Baker said.

She wants to know why the medical examiner’s office didn’t check fingerprints when Jade’s body was brought in without any identification.

We tried to ask that question, but Pierce County Medical Examiner Thomas Clark did not respond to Q13 Fox’s requests for an interview.

Clark did release a statement on Wednesday afternoon. It read, in part: “Scientific methods like fingerprints, DNA and dental records are not used unless necessary because they are time-consuming, expensive and create delays. We are reviewing the circumstances and will adjust our practices.”

A candlelight vigil was held Thursday night for Jade by her family and friends.  Samantha Kennedy was there.

Aubrey said no one has apologized to her family, or offered her any explanations. She thinks she deserves more.

“I don’t have a daughter, but I should have known right away,” Aubrey said. “They should have fingerprinted her, instead of putting her in the freezer and leaving her there. That’s the way I look at it.”

Aubrey’s family also wants the driver who hit jade to be held responsible.

The Washington State Patrol said the driver showed some signs of impairment after the accident, but no charges have been filed against him because the results of his blood test have not come back yet.


Pierce County Medical Examiner’s Office identified body of woman killed in accident as that of Samantha Kennedy (pictured). Her mother was devastated; she found out three days later it was a mistake. (Photo courtesy of family)

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

1 Comment

  • Leah

    Thanks Pierce County for allowing a Mother to not only FEEL as though something happened…TOLD not to worry…. Only to be PUNCHED by REALITY LATER…. WOW~ I was on the phone with my Boyfriend when I heard All the sirens in the back ground. We KNEW something awful had happened. So sorry to the Family & All the Friends who Lost her~ Blessings to you All~

    As for the person who hit her, I can not imagine the horror of that either. I do not know if you were slightly…totally…or completely Drunk….or if you were simply a distracted driver, completely Sober. This is something that you will have to live with for the rest of your life.

    I could not imagine and would not want to imagine actually hitting someone with my vehicle. I actually ALMOST hit someone in a CROSSWALK last Summer, that was/is inconveniently placed half way around a corner on the right hand side.. near an ISLAND!!! Uhmm hello if u never been to the neighborhood before… (clears throat) I LIKE CORNERS…going the speed limit of course. :) I was going 35-40. There is no slow down signs near the island… can u see how this could be bad? No need to answer.

    The LOOK in his eyes & the way he tried to HOP/RUN out of the way and was getting no where…THANK GOD I HAVE GREAT BRAKES!!!!!!! THANK GOD…. I was able to hysterically laugh and tell him HOW SORRY I WAS for scaring the crap out of him & that I was just as scared!

    Unless you don't have a heart, or compassion, or EMPATHY & UNDERSTANDING for this family… you should go out of your way to make sure that the friends and Family are given an Apology from YOU…. at the very least.

    You owe them that.

    I would not wish this story or 95% of them.. on anyone :(