10-year-old Philadelphia girl allowed to get in line for lung transplant

This is an archived article and the information in the article may be outdated. Please look at the time stamp on the story to see when it was last updated.

SEATTLE — A Philadelphia girl with cystic fibrosis desperately needs a lung transplant.

Sarah-MurnaghanHer family’s fight to save her life ended up in federal court.

On Wednesday, a judge ruled in favor of the family, sparking renewed hope for the little girl and talk over transplant rules.

Local youngster Dhontay Chamroen-Moran was born with a bad kidney. Last week, the teenager finally received a transplant.

In the past 29 years, he is one of more than 700 kids leaving Seattle Children’s with a new lease on life.

“I am grateful to the hospital staff,’ said Moran.

But there are so many who don’t get to say that.

Sarah Murnaghan has been waiting for 18 months for a lung. The 10-year-old Philadephila girl could die within weeks if she doesn’t get one. Her biggest hurdle to a transplant is her age. Under a nationwide policy children under 12 years old are only eligible for a pediatric lung, which are hard to come by.

“Sarah has declined in the last two days but we are very excited with the news today that she will have the opportunity to be equally judged and have the opportunity to receive lungs,” said father Fran Murnaghan.

The Health and Human Services Secretary says the age limits are there for a good reason.

“It’s transplant surgeons and healthcare providers who design the protocol”said Kathleen Sebelius.

That dilemma is something Dr. Andre Dick deals with every day at Seattle Children’s.

“It’s a challenging thing to deal with limited resources and allocate those resources,” the doctor said.

Seattle Children’s does not perform lung transplants but the surgeon weighed in about Sarah’s case.

“In the end by just making that exception there are people that will be waiting and dying on the list because of that, you can change it and say there should be no age limits but the bottleneck is there are not enough donors,” said Dick.

Right now 40 kids are on the transplant waiting list at Seattle Children’s. Most of them in need of liver or kidney. The good thing about most organs is that there isn’t a strict age limit like when it comes to lungs. As Dhontay counts his blessings, he says he is thinking of Sarah, someone he doesn’t know but definitely understands.

“She deserves the lung more than I deserve a kidney because I can live on dialysis but she cannot live without a lung,” said Dhontay

Some lawmakers are on Sarah’s side, saying the age restrictions are outdated and that medical advancements safely allow young patients to handle adult lungs.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s


  • Joe

    The secretary of Health and Human Services shall determine. Well, Sebelius can’t set president of compassion of because the Death Panels would be expected to show it as soon as Obummer care has dug it roots in like a wart.
    This girl is just a taste of what the rationing of heath care will be, oh and by the way,they will soon put illegal aliens from Mexico in the front of the line before you and your kids, your just a tax payer, the tax consumers are more important for votes.

  • joe

    The lack of compassion by that big government bureaucrat is actually justified, it’s a necessary sacrifice, you’ve got to break some eggs in order to make an omelet you see. That little kid serves a better purpose dead than alive to the Obama care agenda of health care control by big government department spending. As always with the mode of operation with the sneaky Democrats: “the ends justifies the means”. Kinda’ like the government heads using the power of the IRS to control politics.

Notice: you are using an outdated browser. Microsoft does not recommend using IE as your default browser. Some features on this website, like video and images, might not work properly. For the best experience, please upgrade your browser.