Carnation murder case: ‘I knew she was eventually going to hurt someone’

This is an archived article and the information in the article may be outdated. Please look at the time stamp on the story to see when it was last updated.

SEATTLE — In the Carnation murder case, a woman who has not yet faced a jury is now the focus at her boyfriend’s trial.

Joe McEnroe could face the death penalty in the killings of Michele Anderson’s six family members. He has admitted to police his part in shooting and killing his girlfriend’s family, including pulling the trigger on her young niece and nephew.

But on Thursday, jurors heard from another one of Anderson’s former boyfriends, Marc Mann. He called her unstable and told them he’s not surprised she turned violent.

“I knew she was eventually going to hurt someone,” said Mann. “You have a feeling. You just know it’s going to happen.”

McEnroe’s defense team continues to focus on Michele Anderson, who they say pushed McEnroe into taking part in the killings.

In her own confession to police, Anderson said she felt slighted and angry at her brother, Scott, for not paying back a loan, and held it against the rest of her family for not backing her. That led to the plan to kill them on Christmas Eve 2007.

“Yes, it was premeditated and yes, I was fed up with everything,” Anderson said during police interviews.

On the witness stand, Mann described Anderson as angry, controlling and paranoid, and said she became more unstable when she began taking anti-depressants off and on. He also told jurors she sometimes wanted to hurt or kill people.

“She didn’t like people and she thought people didn’t like her,” said Mann. “She felt that everyone was cruel, abusive monsters.”

McEnroe’s defense team hopes that by convincing jurors that McEnroe was pushed by Anderson to take part in the killings that he can avoid the death penalty.

Michelle Anderson’s murder trial is scheduled for next fall.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s


  • Michele Genie Walker

    Thank god she finally in prison, never bought her mental BS that held up this case, she was spoiled, jealous of brother and just wanted her way, this was revenge, very sad she did not get death penalty, that family and babies deserve ultimate justice. She slaughtered family and 2 babies in cold blood just cuz she did not get her way, I pray that she gets all deserved in prison. Sad but that is what murder does to survivors. A whole family just wiped out and it’s happening more and more, if death was imposed perhaps wackos would think twice. I pray for peace for murder victims she created. I hope she is haunted but doubt it, she made it all about her as usual. RIP for whole family. TRAGIC.